Preprint · Aug 2026
An invented symbol system with no sounds looks just like the Indus script
Raghavendra · arXiv 2608.02999 (SIGIL)

In a sentence
If a made-up emblem system matches every statistic, statistics alone cannot prove the signs are writing.
In plain words
He built an artificial system of emblems with no language behind it. It matched the Indus script on every measure he could compute exactly. Programs that “decode” by matching dictionaries happily read it as English, Sanskrit or Tamil. So those numbers cannot settle whether the Indus signs write a language.
Technical detail
SIGIL is a sound-free emblem generator matched to Indus on every exactly scorable statistic (entropy, Zipf, n-grams, positional concentration). Dictionary-hit decoders produce fluent readings of it in several languages. This closes entropy- and Zipf-style arguments in both directions.
What we take from it
Using itEvery new claim we test must also fail on SIGIL-style emblem data. We use it as a standing negative control.