← Back to News

Debate · 2009–2014

Does sign order prove it is a language? The numbers say no

Rao et al. 2009 (Science); Sproat 2010, 2014 (Language) · Science 324; Language 90:457

Illustration: a stone cut with two overlapping range bands and a marker where they overlap.
Editorial illustration, not a real object or a transcription.

In a sentence

A measure of how predictable the next sign is put Indus near languages. Critics showed non-writing scores there too.

In plain words

Rao’s team measured how predictable the next sign is and found the Indus script sits in the same band as languages. Sproat replied that symbol systems that are not writing can score the same way, and that two better measures put Indus with non-writing. Later work, including SIGIL, settled it: these numbers alone cannot decide.

Technical detail

Conditional entropy of sign bigrams (Rao et al. 2009); n-gram restoration of missing signs (Yadav et al. 2010, PLoS ONE). Sproat (2010, 2014): the entropy band does not separate writing from non-writing; two measures that do put Indus and Pictish on the non-linguistic side.

What we take from it

Closed

Treat entropy, Zipf and n-gram arguments as closed in both directions.

Read our result in the repository.

← Back to News