← Back to News

Paper · 2004

The case that the signs might not be writing at all

Farmer, Sproat and Witzel · Electronic Journal of Vedic Studies 11(2)

Illustration: a seal with a short text beside an emblem shield.
Editorial illustration, not a real object or a transcription.

In a sentence

Texts are very short, and many signs are rare: maybe these are symbols, not a script.

In plain words

The authors pointed out that Indus texts are very short, about five signs on average, that many signs appear only once, and that no long text has ever been found. They argued the signs could be a system of symbols, like road signs or coats of arms, rather than writing that records speech.

Technical detail

Arguments from text length (mean about 4.6 signs, longest single-surface text 17), rare-sign frequency and the absence of long texts. Sparked the language-vs-symbols debate continued by Rao et al. 2009 and Sproat 2010 and 2014.

What we take from it

Using it

We test whether the signs are language at all, instead of assuming it.

Read our result in the repository.

← Back to News